THE ELECTRONIC RHYTHM ARCHIVEMACHINE EXHIBITION / 1978
ROLAND / JAPAN / 1978COMPURHYTHM

MEMORY ENTERS THE RHYTHM BOX

CR–78

A preset rhythm.
A very personal answer.

Wood, coloured keys and four small memories. A machine that could supply the beat—or remember yours.

▶ Hear its voices
Roland CompuRhythm CR-78. Big Beat Collection.

THE INSTRUMENT / AN INTRODUCTION

Press a rhythm.
Then answer it.

The front panel offers a small world of ready-made music: waltz, rock, bossa nova, samba. Beside it sits a programmer. You could accept what Roland had prepared, change what reached the speakers, or write a rhythm the machine had never played before.

The CR-78 makes that choice physical. The wood cabinet and coloured buttons belong to the familiar rhythm box. Four yellow memory keys introduce something else: a place for the musician’s own decisions.

This was a computer-controlled instrument, but the computer stored timing, not audio. Its percussion came from analogue circuits. Presets, memory, cancellation, variation and the mix were different parts of one musical surface.

01 / THE PAIR / 1978ROLAND COMPURHYTHM

Two rhythm boxes.
One new possibility.

Roland’s October 1978 Japanese catalogue presents the CR-68 and CR-78 together. The CR-78 is priced at ¥105,000. The extra facility is visible at the centre of its panel: four locations for a rhythm written by the user.

The ready-made vocabulary remained. There were 34 preset rhythms, with arrangement controls around them. Memory added authorship to accompaniment; a musician could retain a recurring part instead of reaching for the same factory selection every time.

The catalogue matters because it shows the instrument at its original moment. Later records had not yet supplied its reputation. A buyer met a cabinet, a price, a panel and a proposition.

Open the October 1978 catalogue ↗
Roland General Catalogue, October 1978. CR-68 and CR-78 appear together.
02 / THE PERFORMANCE SURFACEROLAND COMPURHYTHM

The rhythm is fixed.
The arrangement moves.

A preset does not end the conversation. Cancel Voice lets a player remove selected groups of percussion. The Add Voice sliders bring other elements into the balance. A rhythm can become sparse, bright or newly emphatic without consuming one of the four memories.

Variation works at a larger scale. An automatic event can arrive after a chosen number of measures; a manual control lets the player call it. A fill, a break or a move between A and B changes how a repeated part meets the next section.

Fade-in and fade-out give the box its own entrance and exit. These are practical arranging controls. They also explain why a rhythm machine could remain part of a finished performance after it had helped start the song.

The preset bank and A/B selector. Collection photograph.
Variation and measure.
Fade and Cancel Voice.
Balance and Add Voice.
03 / THE PROGRAMMERROLAND COMPURHYTHM

Four memories.
Room for a song.

The four programme keys are not four recordings. Each recalls stored trigger decisions for a two-measure rhythm. Four instrument parts and accent fit within the documented memory system.

The selected voice is written, then another part is added. This way of working asks a player to build the rhythm in layers. The lights tell you which memory is active; the pattern inside it has to be heard.

Roland provided two routes into those decisions. The TS-1 writes events against the running clock. The WS-1 uses separate BEAT and REST actions, stepping through 8, 12, 24 or 48 divisions of a measure. Both methods lead into the same store.

Four locations are enough to suggest an arrangement: a stripped section, a fuller answer, a different transition. They are a small set of reusable musical decisions, not a modern library of hundreds of patterns.

Explore the existing four-memory teaching model ↗
The instrument selector, write controls and four programme memories. Collection photograph.
04 / THE VOICESLISTEN TO THE INSTRUMENT

The computer conducts.
The circuits speak.

The rhythm decides when. A resonator, a noise circuit or a metallic oscillator gives each event a body.

The owner’s manual describes eleven core percussion sources. The voices do not share one universal circuit at different pitches: resonant drums, short bright attacks, filtered noise and inharmonic metallic generators make different kinds of sound.

Try six recorded selections from the Studio’s existing Alex Ball reference bank. These are recordings of individual sounds; the controls here play those recordings.

Choose a voice to listen.

Inside the cabinet: timing and sound +

The NEC µPD8048 control processor scans the panel and organises events. Factory decisions reside in ROM; the user’s pattern information is held in battery-backed RAM. The processor sends triggers to a separate analogue voice system.

This separation explains several different histories inside one object. The stored pattern can survive a power cycle; the voice can change as components age; the same pattern can be played with different controls and gain settings. Timing memory is not a digital recording of the percussion.

The service adjustment table gives concrete design targets: bass drum around 62.5 Hz with a 100 ms decay, and snare body around 340 Hz with a 60 ms decay. These are service references for the original circuitry, not settings exposed by this recorded-sound player.

Roland CR-78 Service Notes. Control, memory and clock block diagram.
05 / OUTSIDE THE CABINETROLAND COMPURHYTHM

A rhythm box
with other conversations.

The back of the machine changes the scale of the story. An external clock input can let another system supply timing. A trigger output can send rhythmic events onward. Pedal connections bring start/stop and variation within reach of a performer’s feet.

Audio, clock and trigger are different relationships. The CR-78 has no MIDI interface; a socket that looks familiar does not establish compatibility. The service notes specify the electrical timing of its external clock.

In a studio, these connections could make the rhythm box part of a larger electronic arrangement. The pattern might be audible, or it might help determine when something else happened.

Clock, write, trigger, pedal and audio connections. Complete collection photograph.
06 / RECORDSFOUR WAYS INTO A SONG

A preset can become
a personal signature.

Combination, original programming, adaptation and a writing prompt: these records put the machine to different work. Follow the participant accounts as well as the music.

COMBINATION

Blondie
Heart of Glass

Roland’s production account identifies Mambo and Beguine in the CR-78 foundation, alongside its trigger role in the keyboard figure. The machine participates in the arrangement as both sound and timing.

Watch the official video ↗Read the account ↗

ADAPTATION

Phil Collins
In the Air Tonight

Collins describes adapting a supplied rhythm and adding a programmed bass-drum part while writing at home. The retained electronic foundation precedes the acoustic drum entrance.

Watch the official video ↗Read the account ↗

A WRITING PROMPT

Hall & Oates
I Can’t Go for That

Roland’s retrospective recounts Daryl Hall beginning with Rock 1 and developing the bass part and chords against it. A factory rhythm could give a new song its starting point.

Watch the official video ↗Read the account ↗
THE READING ROOMGO FURTHER

Follow the circuit.
Keep the whole object.

The original owner’s manual explains what the player can do. The service notes show how the control and voice systems cooperate. The catalogue and advertisement show how Roland presented the instrument to its first customers.

The existing CR-78 field guide keeps deeper programming and engineering material, revision-aware service context and later modelled versions. It remains part of this exhibition’s source base and will be preserved during integration.

The deeper research record, recording evidence and visual archive remain available below.

THE COMPLETE RESEARCH ARCHIVECURRENT MUSEUM EVIDENCE
Open the deeper dossier, recording register and visual evidence +

Roland dates the CR-78 to 1978. Its owner’s manual presents 34 preset rhythms, four user-pattern memories and performance controls that made fixed patterns surprisingly malleable.

Sources (6)
  1. Open source 1 ↗
  2. Open source 2 ↗
  3. Open source 3 ↗
  4. Open source 4 ↗
  5. Open source 5 ↗
  6. Open source 6 ↗

The machine in the record

Phil Collins and Leland Sklar in a studio photograph.
Phil Collins and Leland Sklar in the studio. The image supplies period studio context for the documented CR-78 demo foundation; it does not identify the machine in frame.
Cover artwork for Phil Collins — In the Air Tonight.
Record artwork for Phil Collins — In the Air Tonight; it identifies the release, not the machine or a recording session.

Phil Collins / “In the Air Tonight”.

Phil Collins kept an adapted CR-78 rhythm from the home demo at the foundation of “In the Air Tonight”. The later acoustic fill changes the scale of the record, but the machine’s measured pulse is there from the start, holding the song in its famous state of suspense.

Read Classic Tracks: Phil Collins’ In the Air Tonight ↗

More records in the archive

The machine keeps turning up.

Die Krupps performing at the Amphi Festival in 2014.
Die Krupps at the Amphi Festival in 2014, photographed by Atamari. It identifies Jürgen Engler’s group in the CR-78 story; it is not a photograph of the Stahlwerksynfonie sessions or the machine.

Jürgen Engler / Die Krupps / Stahlwerksynfonie

Jürgen Engler says the programmed drums on Die Krupps’ Stahlwerksynfonie came from a Roland CompuRhythm CR-78 wired into a large sequencer so individual voices could be patched into new patterns.

Read How I Got That Sound: Jürgen Engler ↗
Throbbing Gristle in their studio: Chris Carter, Cosey Fanni Tutti, Genesis P-Orridge and Peter Christopherson.
Throbbing Gristle / Chris Carter — “Hamburger Lady” era: retained artwork identifies the release context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Throbbing Gristle / Chris Carter / “Hamburger Lady” era

Chris Carter calls the modified Roland CompuRhythm CR-78 Throbbing Gristle’s main drum machine for a long stretch, synchronized to a Roland System 100 sequencer and Sleazy’s sampler.

Read Classic Tracks: Throbbing Gristle’s “Hamburger Lady” ↗

Reported association

Cover artwork for Blondie — Heart of Glass.
Heart of Glass brings the CR-78 attribution into Blondie’s own visual world; the sleeve identifies the release, not a full multitrack allocation.

Blondie / Heart of Glass

The CR-78 forms the opening rhythmic bed, combining Mambo and Beguine patterns and supplying a trigger pulse for Jimmy Destri’s SH-5 figure.

Read Sound Behind the Song: “Heart of Glass” by Blondie ↗
Cover artwork for Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark — Enola Gay.
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark / Andy McCluskey — Enola Gay: retained artwork gives this source-backed artist account a record context; it does not itself prove the machine, a specific sound, or a recording session.

Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark / Andy McCluskey / Enola Gay

McCluskey says OMD programmed the CR-78 drum pattern that became the bed of Enola Gay.

Read How I wrote “Enola Gay” by OMD’s Andy McCluskey ↗

Reported association

Cover artwork for Daryl Hall & John Oates — I Can't Go for That (No Can Do).
Daryl Hall & John Oates — I Can’t Go for That (No Can Do): retained artwork identifies the release context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Daryl Hall & John Oates / I Can’t Go for That (No Can Do)

Roland’s historical overview reports use of the CR-78 Rock 1 pattern as a writing prompt.

Read CR-78: The Whole Story ↗

Reported association

Cover artwork for Ultravox — Vienna.
Ultravox — Vienna: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Ultravox / Vienna

Roland’s historical overview reports the CR-78 Rock 4 pattern on Vienna.

Read CR-78: The Whole Story ↗

Reported association

Chris de Burgh / Lady in Red

Roland’s historical overview reports the CR-78 Enka pattern on Lady in Red.

Read CR-78: The Whole Story ↗

Reported association

Cover artwork for John Foxx — Metamatic.
John Foxx — Metamatic: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

John Foxx / Metamatic

Roland’s historical overview reports CR-78 use across the album.

Read CR-78: The Whole Story ↗
Cover artwork for Joy Division — Closer.
Stephen Morris / Joy Division — Decades: retained artwork identifies the release context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Stephen Morris / Joy Division / Decades

Stephen Morris recalls Martin Hannett directing him to use a Roland CR-78 for Joy Division’s Decades, and remembers wrestling with its programming accessories.

Read Stephen Morris — A Career in Gear ↗
Warren Cann photographed for Electronics & Music Maker in 1981.
Warren Cann in Electronics & Music Maker, April 1981. The profile’s text places a Roland CR-78 beside his TR-77 and connects its metallic rhythm to “Astradyne”; the portrait itself does not show either machine.

Warren Cann / Ultravox / Vienna and Astradyne

A 1981 profile places a Roland CR-78 beside Warren Cann’s TR-77, describing its programmed rhythm functions and connecting its metallic beat to “Astradyne”.

Read Ultravox ↗
Cover artwork for Detlef Funder and Bernd Sevens — Stumm.
Detlef Funder and Bernd Sevens — Stumm: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Detlef Funder and Bernd Sevens / Stumm

The CR-78 is named in the duo’s stripped 1980 studio setup.

Read Detlef Funder and Bernd Sevens / Stumm ↗
Cover artwork for Stephen Parsick — polarity redux.
Stephen Parsick — polarity redux: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Stephen Parsick / polarity redux

Stephen Parsick recalls buying a Roland CR-78 in July 1991 and immediately using it on the basement recordings later collected as polarity redux.

Read Stephen Parsick / polarity redux ↗
Cover artwork for Steve Moore — Primitive Neural Pathways.
Steve Moore — Primitive Neural Pathways: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Steve Moore / Primitive Neural Pathways

Steve Moore lists a Roland Compurhythm CR-78 among the instruments used for Primitive Neural Pathways.

Read Primitive Neural Pathways ↗
We Are KING performing in a studio, photographed for Guitar Center.
We Are KING photographed for Guitar Center. Amber Strother’s accompanying account describes the CR-78 as a songwriting companion; the photograph shows the duo’s working room, not a CR-78.

We Are KING / Amber Strother / Songwriting and idea development

Amber Strother describes the Roland CR-78 as the drum machine she turns to for quickly fleshing out song ideas and finding new rhythmic textures.

Read Guitar Center / We Are KING: Make Music ↗
Cover artwork for Gris Futuro — Nowadaze.
Gris Futuro — Nowadaze: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Gris Futuro / Nowadaze

Gris Futuro list a Roland CR-78 in the setup for Nowadaze, with Karolis Budreckas specifically thanked for CR-78 duties.

Read Gris Futuro — Nowadaze ↗
Cover artwork for Those Attractive Magnets — Electromagnetic Pulse.
Those Attractive Magnets — Electromagnetic Pulse: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Those Attractive Magnets / Electromagnetic Pulse

Those Attractive Magnets credit a Roland CR-78 among the instruments used for recordings made between 1980 and 1983.

Read Those Attractive Magnets / Electromagnetic Pulse ↗
Cover artwork for Lunar Maps — Lunar Maps.
Lunar Maps — Lunar Maps: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

Lunar Maps / Lunar Maps

Lunar Maps list the Roland CR-78 among the drum machines used for this 2010 recording.

Read Lunar Maps / Lunar Maps ↗
Cover artwork for TenGrams — The Defect of Equality.
TenGrams — The Defect of Equality: retained artwork identifies the release or source-recording context, not a machine, session or sound allocation.

TenGrams / The Defect of Equality

TenGrams name a Roland CR-78 among the drum machines used on The Defect of Equality.

Read TenGrams — The Defect of Equality ↗
Cover artwork for L’Avenir / Jason Sloan — L’Avenir | Kiss of the Whip - 2.
L’Avenir / Jason Sloan — L’Avenir | Kiss of the Whip - 2: retained release artwork gives the documented machine story a record-world context; it does not depict the hardware, a session, or an individual track allocation.

L’Avenir / Jason Sloan / L’Avenir | Kiss of the Whip - 2

Jason Sloan’s release inventory for L’Avenir lists a Roland CR-78.

Read L’Avenir / Kiss of the Whip — L’Avenir | Kiss of the Whip - 2 ↗
Cover artwork for Simon Pott / isvisible isinvisible — Isvisible Isinvisible.
Record artwork for Simon Pott / isvisible isinvisible — Isvisible Isinvisible; it identifies the release, not the machine or a recording session.

Simon Pott / isvisible isinvisible / Isvisible Isinvisible

Simon Pott lists a Roland CR-78 among the sound sources for Isvisible Isinvisible.

Read isvisible isinvisible — Isvisible Isinvisible ↗
Tyler Pope photographed for MusicRadar in 2023.
Tyler Pope in MusicRadar’s 2023 interview. He identifies the Roland CR-78 as part of the one-drum-machine, one-synth setup for Nur Weil Ich Kann; the photograph does not show the instrument or a recording session.

Tyler Pope / Nur Weil Ich Kann

Tyler Pope says James Murphy urged him to make an EP using one drum machine and one synth, prompting him to obtain a Roland CR-78 and ARP Odyssey for Nur Weil Ich Kann.

Read Tyler Pope: CR-78 and ARP Odyssey for Nur Weil Ich Kann ↗
Julie Campbell, who records as LoneLady, photographed for MusicRadar in 2021.
Julie Campbell / LoneLady in MusicRadar’s 2021 feature. Her account names this machine among the real drum-machine samples layered for Former Things; the portrait does not show a machine or a recording session.

LoneLady / Julie Campbell / Former Things

Julie Campbell says Former Things layered real samples from a Roland CR-78 among its drum-machine palette.

Read LoneLady: a songwriter who turns her music and politics into art ↗
01 // Landmark

The rhythm box that invited an answer

The CR-78 looks like a classic preset accompaniment machine: rows of named dances and grooves at the push of a button. Its microcomputer also retains four user patterns, letting a domestic rhythm box carry a song’s own pulse as well as its supplied foxtrot or bossa nova.

Sources (2)
  1. Open source 1 ↗
  2. Open source 2 ↗

02 // Landmark

Fixed patterns, open doors

The owner’s manual lists eleven percussion sources and 34 preset rhythms. Add Voice, Metallic Beat and Cancel Voice reshape a pattern; fill, rolling and break interrupt it; fade-in and fade-out give it an entrance and exit. The machine offers a compact vocabulary of musical decisions.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

03 // Landmark

Four memories for a different beat

The CR-78’s four memory positions gave musicians room to retain patterns that did not appear on the factory selector. Roland’s later history marks that programmable turn as a bridge between standard preset accompaniment and the more open drum machines that followed.

Sources (2)
  1. Open source 1 ↗
  2. Open source 2 ↗

04 // Landmark

A song begins at home

Phil Collins has described beginning “In the Air Tonight” with a CR-78 rhythm, subtracting selected sounds and adding a programmed bass-drum part before keyboard chords and an early vocal at home. The finished recording kept that foundation before Hugh Padgham’s acoustic drums delivered its famous fill.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

05 // Landmark

A precise kind of flexibility

The CR-78’s appeal lies in its limits: distinctive sounds and a modest set of ways to interrupt, subtract from and write around them. It supplies a beat, then leaves space for a player to make the beat feel chosen.

Sources (2)
  1. Open source 1 ↗
  2. Open source 2 ↗

06 // Landmark

Blondie’s machine-led disco opening

“Heart of Glass” begins with the CR-78 before Clem Burke turns the groove into a full drum performance. Roland’s account identifies the Mambo-and-Beguine combination and the machine’s trigger role in Jimmy Destri’s SH-5 figure: the preset box is not background decoration, but an opening device that also reaches into the song’s keyboard pulse.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

07 // Landmark

Andy McCluskey programs Enola Gay

Andy McCluskey recalls buying a CR-78, programming the beat for “Enola Gay”, and building the whole track on that rhythm bed. The story makes the machine’s programmable memory feel less like a late feature on an accompanist and more like the hinge of an international synth-pop record.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

08 // Landmark

Preset patterns with long afterlives

Roland’s historical overview also associates the CR-78 with Hall & Oates’ “I Can’t Go for That (No Can Do)”, Ultravox’s “Vienna”, Chris de Burgh’s “Lady in Red” and John Foxx’s Metamatic. These are reported connections, included as listening leads rather than as new claims about each track’s complete production chain.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

09 // Landmark

The preset became the hook

The CR-78’s patterns were fixed, but the records made with them were not. Phil Collins retained an adapted rhythm from the home demo of “In the Air Tonight”; Andy McCluskey says OMD programmed the bed of “Enola Gay”; and Roland’s historical account traces specific CR-78 patterns into “Heart of Glass”, “Vienna” and “Lady in Red”. The enduring lesson is that a preset can be a starting point, a clock and a character all at once.

Sources (4)
  1. Open source 1 ↗
  2. Open source 2 ↗
  3. Open source 3 ↗
  4. Open source 4 ↗

10 // Landmark

John Foxx gives the preset a private life

Roland’s historical overview associates the CR-78 with John Foxx’s Metamatic. It is a reported connection rather than a session transcript, but it fits the record’s small-room atmosphere: a preset rhythm machine becoming a steady, impersonal companion to Foxx’s electronic solitude.

Source (1)
  1. Open source 1 ↗

MUSIC HISTORY

On record

  • Phil Collins — In the Air Tonight. CR-78 supplied the adapted rhythm foundation retained from the home demo. Source ↗
  • Blondie — Heart of Glass. The CR-78 forms the opening rhythmic bed, combining Mambo and Beguine patterns and supplying a trigger pulse for Jimmy Destri’s SH-5 figure. Source ↗
  • Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark / Andy McCluskey — Enola Gay. McCluskey says OMD programmed the CR-78 drum pattern that became the bed of Enola Gay. Source ↗
  • Daryl Hall & John Oates — I Can’t Go for That (No Can Do). Roland’s historical overview reports use of the CR-78 Rock 1 pattern as a writing prompt. Source ↗
  • Ultravox — Vienna. Roland’s historical overview reports the CR-78 Rock 4 pattern on Vienna. Source ↗
  • Chris de Burgh — Lady in Red. Roland’s historical overview reports the CR-78 Enka pattern on Lady in Red. Source ↗
  • John Foxx — Metamatic. Roland’s historical overview reports CR-78 use across the album. Source ↗
  • Kate Bush — “Sat In Your Lap” demo. A published production history says Kate Bush used a Roland CR-78 while tracking the demo that became “Sat In Your Lap”. Source ↗
  • Stephen Morris / Joy Division — Decades. Stephen Morris recalls Martin Hannett directing him to use a Roland CR-78 for Joy Division’s Decades, and remembers wrestling with its programming accessories. Source ↗
  • Warren Cann / Ultravox — Vienna and Astradyne. A 1981 profile places a Roland CR-78 beside Warren Cann’s TR-77, describing its programmed rhythm functions and connecting its metallic beat to “Astradyne”. Source ↗
  • Detlef Funder and Bernd Sevens — Stumm. The CR-78 is named in the duo’s stripped 1980 studio setup. Source ↗
  • Stephen Parsick — polarity redux. Stephen Parsick recalls buying a Roland CR-78 in July 1991 and immediately using it on the basement recordings later collected as polarity redux. Source ↗
  • Steve Moore — Primitive Neural Pathways. Steve Moore lists a Roland Compurhythm CR-78 among the instruments used for Primitive Neural Pathways. Source ↗
  • We Are KING / Amber Strother — Songwriting and idea development. Amber Strother describes the Roland CR-78 as the drum machine she turns to for quickly fleshing out song ideas and finding new rhythmic textures. Source ↗
  • Gris Futuro — Nowadaze. Gris Futuro list a Roland CR-78 in the setup for Nowadaze, with Karolis Budreckas specifically thanked for CR-78 duties. Source ↗
  • Those Attractive Magnets — Electromagnetic Pulse. Those Attractive Magnets credit a Roland CR-78 among the instruments used for recordings made between 1980 and 1983. Source ↗
  • Lunar Maps — Lunar Maps. Lunar Maps list the Roland CR-78 among the drum machines used for this 2010 recording. Source ↗
  • TenGrams — The Defect of Equality. TenGrams name a Roland CR-78 among the drum machines used on The Defect of Equality. Source ↗
  • L’Avenir / Jason Sloan — L’Avenir | Kiss of the Whip - 2. Jason Sloan’s release inventory for L’Avenir lists a Roland CR-78. Source ↗

Sources

  1. Roland Drum Machine Chronicle: 1964–2016
  2. Classic Tracks: Phil Collins’ In the Air Tonight
  3. Roland CompuRhythm CR-78 Owner’s Manual
  4. Sound Behind the Song: “Heart of Glass” by Blondie
  5. How I wrote “Enola Gay” by OMD’s Andy McCluskey
  6. CR-78: The Whole Story

The visual archive

Further visual evidence.

These displayed records are labelled by their documented role, date and source; source-only records are listed separately below.

Sources for images shown earlier (22)